Bihar at the Crossroads, The Duality of Women’s Empowerment and the Scourge of Migration
Bihar, a state that cradles the echoes of ancient Indian empires and the birthplace of Buddhism, stands today at a critical juncture in its modern history. Its narrative is one of profound duality—a tale of remarkable social transformation shadowed by persistent economic despair. As the state navigates its political future, this dichotomy defines its present and will chart its course for decades to come. On one hand, there is an undeniable, state-led revolution in women’s empowerment, lifting female literacy and financial independence to unprecedented heights. On the other, there is the relentless exodus of its male workforce, a silent indictment of a failed industrial and agricultural ecosystem. This is the story of a state waiting for its moment in the sun, a moment perpetually delayed by the unresolved crisis of employment.
A Haunting Past: The Image That Symbolized a Bygone Era
To understand the magnitude of Bihar’s social transformation, one must first recall its recent past. The author, Shashi Shekhar, Editor-in-Chief of Hindustan, provides a poignant vignette from the last decade of the 20th century. Travelling from Patna to Dhanbad (now in Jharkhand) on a cold winter morning, he witnessed a scene that encapsulated the state’s deep-seated deprivation. A woman, draped in a single sari, stood hesitantly at the edge of a slush-filled pond, preparing to bathe in the bitter cold. Her profound vacillation suggested she had no other garment to change into. The indignity was compounded as passersby leered, and she was forced to rinse her mouth with the same murky water.
This single image is a powerful synecdoche for the Bihar of that era—a state plagued by poverty, a lack of dignity, and the systemic disempowerment of women. It was a place where basic human needs were a daily struggle, and opportunity was a scarce commodity. “A lot of water has flowed in the Ganga and the Kosi since then,” the author notes, and with it, a sea change has begun to sweep across the state, particularly for its women.
The Silent Revolution: Women Wielding the Pen and the Pistol
The most significant and perhaps most under-reported story in Bihar over the last two decades has been the dramatic upliftment of its women. This change is not accidental; it is the result of deliberate policy interventions and a societal shift.
1. The Literacy Leap: In the year 2000, the female literacy rate in Bihar was a dismal 33%. Today, it stands at an estimated 73.9%. This is more than a statistical jump; it is a social earthquake. Mass literacy campaigns and focused efforts on girls’ education have unlocked cognitive potential on a massive scale, creating a generation of women who can read, write, and engage with the world in ways their mothers could not.
2. Economic Agency through SHGs: Perhaps the most transformative initiative has been the promotion of Self-Help Groups (SHGs). Bihar now boasts 1.06 million active SHGs, encompassing 14.5 million women. These groups are not just saving circles; they are engines of micro-entrepreneurship and financial independence. The women have availed loans totalling a staggering ₹415,000 crore from banks, and their loan repayment record—an astounding 99%—is far superior to that of men. This financial discipline has shattered stereotypes and established women as credible and reliable economic actors.
3. Entry into the Workforce: The state government’s 35% quota for women in government jobs has been a game-changer. It has drastically improved the gender ratio in the workplace. Today, women constitute 37% of the police force in Bihar—a domain once considered exclusively male. They are literally “wielding the pistol,” a symbol of authority and public service. Furthermore, with 261,000 women teachers, they are shaping the next generation, ensuring that the legacy of empowerment continues.
This collective progress has fundamentally altered the social fabric. The scenes of indignity from the 1990s are, as the author states, “guarded against” today. Women have emerged as a formidable, aware, and independent demographic, and their high voter turnout (60% in the 2015 and 2020 elections) proves that they are now a decisive political force that every party must woo.
The Other Side of the Coin: The Scourge of Forced Migration
However, this narrative of women’s empowerment tells only half the story. For all the gains in dignity and agency within the household, a parallel narrative of economic despair unfolds outside it. The stark reality is that Bihar has failed to create employment for its vast population. This failure manifests in the forced migration of nearly 30 million people—roughly a quarter of the state’s population—who must leave their homes in search of work.
The roots of this crisis are deep and structural:
-
Industrial Vacuum: There is not a single major manufacturing unit in the state. While the national average for employment generated in manufacturing and infrastructure stands at 16%, Bihar’s share is negligible. This absence of industry means there are no formal, stable job opportunities for the burgeoning youth population.
-
Agricultural Distress: Frequent droughts and floods, combined with fragmented landholdings, have made agriculture an increasingly unviable vocation. A large number of farmers are being forced away from their traditional work, adding to the pool of the unemployed.
-
Crumbling MSME Sector: Small and medium industries, which could have been a source of local employment, are in a state of shambles, unable to compete or thrive in the current economic environment.
The human cost of this failure is immense. The author shares the lament of migrants who returned to their villages for Chhath Puja. Their words are a chorus of pain that echoes across the state.
Gangaram from Madhepura works in a chocolate factory in Bengaluru. His question is rhetorical and heart-wrenching: “Why would we leave our home? We get work here?” He speaks of the emotional toll—weakening bonds with family and society, returning home only once every couple of years, and the deep-seated anger and lack of respect they face in other states.
Sanjay Chandravanshi, who works in Mumbai, makes a plea that is both simple and profound: “Whoever forms the government should focus all their energies on creating employment opportunities in the state. If Bihar sets up factories, then millions like me will not have to go to Delhi, Mumbai, Surat or Bengaluru.”
The Political Conundrum and the Road Ahead
In the ongoing political discourse, employment is, unsurprisingly, a hot-button issue. Every party is busy blaming its opponents and listing grandiose promises. The rhetoric of roti aur rojgar (bread and employment) fills election manifestos and campaign speeches. Yet, the electorate remains skeptical. The central question is whether the leaders who rant about these issues will undertake a constructive approach once they win the elections.
The solution for Bihar is complex but not unknowable. It requires a multi-pronged strategy:
-
Prioritizing Industrial Policy: The state government must move beyond rhetoric and actively court investment with a clear-eyed industrial policy. This involves improving ease of doing business, developing industrial clusters, and leveraging its strengths in sectors like food processing, given its agricultural base.
-
Investing in Infrastructure: Large-scale infrastructure projects—in roads, power, and logistics—are not just creators of temporary jobs but are fundamental prerequisites for attracting private investment.
-
Revitalizing Agriculture: Beyond drought and flood relief, there is a need for a second Green Revolution in Bihar, focused on climate-resilient crops, drip irrigation, and connecting farmers directly to markets to improve profitability.
-
Skill Development: Aligning the state’s education and vocational training systems with the demands of the modern job market is crucial to prepare its youth for the opportunities that do arise.
Conclusion: The Unfinished Agenda of Bihar’s Development
Bihar’s journey is a testament to the fact that social and economic development are two sides of the same coin. The empowerment of women is a monumental achievement that has brought dignity and agency to millions. It has laid a strong social foundation. However, this foundation cannot sustainably support a population if the economic superstructure remains hollowed out.
The state now stands at a precipice. It has proven that it can engineer profound social change. The unfinished agenda is to replicate this success in the economic realm. The wait for Bihar’s moment in the sun, poignantly encapsulated by the young woman’s question years ago—”Kya ab Bihar ki bari hai?” (Is it now Bihar’s turn?)—continues. The answer lies in the state’s ability to convert its empowered human capital into a dynamic economic force, ensuring that its sons do not have to leave home for their mothers and wives to live with dignity. Until then, the sun will remain on the horizon, casting long shadows of migration over the hard-won gains of empowerment.
Questions & Answers (Q&A)
Q1: The article highlights a dramatic improvement in female literacy and workforce participation. What are the key policy interventions that drove this change, and what have been the broader social impacts?
A1: The key policy interventions include a massive push for girls’ education through various state and central schemes, and a landmark 35% quota for women in state government jobs. This quota directly led to a significant increase in women in the police force (37%) and in teaching roles (261,000 women teachers). The broader social impacts are profound. Financially, the proliferation of Self-Help Groups (SHGs), involving 14.5 million women, has granted unprecedented economic agency, with a stellar 99% loan repayment rate building their creditworthiness. Socially, it has restored dignity, reduced vulnerability, and created a formidable, aware female electorate, as evidenced by the 60% women voter turnout. Women have transitioned from being symbols of deprivation to active agents of change, wielding both “pen and pistol.”
Q2: Despite women’s empowerment, why does the author describe migration as a “scourge” and a “silent indictment” of the state’s economy?
A2: Migration is termed a “scourge” because it is not a choice but a forced economic compulsion. It is a “silent indictment” because it directly points to the state’s fundamental failure to create a viable economic ecosystem. The absence of major manufacturing units, the distress in agriculture due to climate shocks, and the crumbling MSME sector have resulted in a complete lack of formal employment. This forces nearly a quarter of the population (30 million people) to leave their homes, leading to the breakdown of family structures, emotional distress, and a sense of disrespect and alienation in host states. The economic gains from remittances are overshadowed by this immense human cost, making it a silent testimony to administrative and industrial failure.
Q3: The article mentions that migrants like Gangaram and Sanjay express a deep emotional toll. What specific aspects of this toll are highlighted, and what does it reveal about the non-economic cost of migration?
A3: The non-economic cost of migration highlighted includes:
-
Weakening Social Bonds: Gangaram mentions that bonds with family and society start weakening, with visits home possible only once every couple of years.
-
Psychological Anguish: He describes the “deepest anger” felt upon leaving, rooted in the uncertainty of “how long we will be away from our loved ones.”
-
Loss of Dignity: Migrants explicitly state they “don’t get any respect in other states,” facing alienation and prejudice.
This reveals that migration is not just an economic transaction but a deeply traumatic experience that erodes the social and emotional fabric of communities, creating a generation torn between economic survival and emotional well-being.
Q4: What is the central contradiction or “duality” that the article identifies in Bihar’s current development model?
A4: The central duality is the clash between profound social progress and profound economic failure. On one hand, the state has successfully engineered a social revolution by empowering women through education, jobs, and financial inclusion. On the other hand, it has completely failed to create a parallel economic infrastructure of jobs and industries for its men and youth. This creates a paradoxical situation where households may be experiencing greater dignity and agency through their women, while simultaneously suffering from the absence and distress of their migrating male members. The gains of development are thus “pale into insignificance” for families fractured by the need for survival.
Q5: The article ends on a skeptical note about political promises. What, according to the analysis, would constitute a “constructive approach” to solving Bihar’s employment crisis, beyond “empty rhetoric”?
A5: A “constructive approach” would require a fundamental shift from populist promises to a concrete, actionable economic strategy. This includes:
-
Active Industrial Promotion: Actively courting investment by improving the ease of doing business and developing sector-specific industrial clusters, moving beyond the current industrial vacuum.
-
Infrastructure-Led Growth: Launching large-scale infrastructure projects in transportation and energy, which create immediate jobs and lay the groundwork for future private investment.
-
Agricultural Modernization: Implementing a climate-resilient agricultural strategy with advanced irrigation, crop diversification, and market linkages to make farming profitable again.
-
Aligning Education with Employment: Overhauling the skill development and education system to equip the youth with relevant skills for the modern job market. It demands a long-term vision focused on building a competitive state economy, not just winning the next election.
